ALBUM REVIEW: Suicide Silence – ‘Graceless’

Artwork for Suicide Silence’s ‘Graceless’

The best word to describe Suicide Silence right now is ‘unfortunate’. In the nine years since their mess of a self-titled album, they’ve been unable to escape its shadow, despite spending every subsequent release trying to redeem themselves. They’ve looked to sweep away the antagonism and dismissal to criticism shown during that cycle, and earn back whatever goodwill they can. To watch them do so has been, in no uncertain terms, pitiable. The deathcore that Suicide Silence once spearheaded has left them in the dust, and going back to basics has the feeling of a duty, not something they believe in. For a band whose assigned mantra in a past lifetime was “You only live once, so go fucking nuts”, Suicide Silence have been exceptionally safe and conservative.

It’s worth dwelling on that specifically now for a couple of reasons. Graceless is the third album stuck in this loop of reproof, making it increasingly difficult to buy that Suicide Silence will ever be the band they once were again. They’re too caught up in this rigmarole to really hack it. More pertinently, though, it’s not like the band themselves aren’t dwelling on it, to the point where even their own self-assessment reads as desperate. Guitarist Mark Heylmun says “People are going to say, ‘This sounds like a Suicide Silence we haven’t heard in a very long time’”. Meanwhile, drummer Dan Kenny calls it “pretty easily [his] favourite Eddie [Hermida]-era album”. Unfair as it may be, it’s impossible to remove statements like that from the context in which they exist, context which Suicide Silence are fully aware of. They know how vital the need to impress is, and to them, firing up the Positive Pull-Quote Machine gets them a head start, as hard as that can be to believe.

The proof, ultimately, is in the pudding, though. And how does that manifest on Graceless, exactly? Is there anything freshly ear-catching to gesture towards a long-suffering Suicide Silence finally coming good? …well, the first instance of that is five tracks in on Cursed Since Birth—a clip of comedian Adam Ray dropping their name during a stand-up set, while doing an impression of Dr. Phil. Yeah.

To be as kind as possible, there’s not no situation where Graceless works. If you’re after deathcore that’s as no-nonsense as it comes, and are dipping into Suicide Silence without an ounce of preexisting baggage, it’ll definitely scratch an itch. You can’t argue that it’s not heavy enough; that’s the one thing that Suicide Silence have consistently gotten right in their course-corrections. Compared to, say, how reactionary the heft of 2020’s Become The Hunter was, however—in which responding to the self-titled’s nu-metal slant took priority over interesting songcraft—Graceless seems to be doing better overall. Between a very streamlined brand of beatdown and Eddie Hermida vomiting suitable quantities of venom, it’s a good benchmark for where Suicide Silence should be. Most legitimately impressive is Ernie Iniguez’s drumming (even if the snare might be a little too sharp at times). There’s a consistent viciousness to it that benefits Graceless as a whole, leaping out in the clattering break on Incisions and a particularly hairy tone on Sour.

And that’s about where any significant discussion ends. It’s not surprising, as is the edict of current-day Suicide Silence to avoid surprise at all cost. Graceless, therefore, doesn’t have a lot of bad in it, but equally as little great. Peel back the upped heaviness and intensity, and it really does just feel like Another Deathcore Album, even when accounting for its more tenured lineage. And that’s been the most frustrating thing about Suicide Silence for the entirety of the 2020s, which apparently still clings to them like an irascible limpet.

Nothing about Graceless aims high, or entertains anything above its station. It might even be a step down in that regard; Remember… You Must Die in 2023 made the effort to play around with old-school death-metal touches, none of which have stuck around. That album also wasn’t very memorable, but that seed of an idea persists in concept outside of it. Graceless has nothing of the sort. Its paraded peaks are like the basics of deathcore—it’s brutal; it’s bloody; it’s ugly. The issue is that it’s not going beyond those. At a point in time when talent is spilling out of that genre and its best can be unbelievably powerful, Suicide Silence inspire nowhere near that excitement on Graceless. Again, it’s most unique, memorable moment comes from a sample that has nothing to do with them.

That all circles back to Suicide Silence’s current state of ‘unfortunate’. With Graceless, the effort to break out the funk they’ve been locked in for nearly a decade can be felt, but they’re so deep in the hole that it’s still not enough. Even as the best of this latest leg, it’s the kind of deathcore stock that’s been fully usurped by more creative acts. Had this followed You Can’t Stop Me and the almighty high it produced, this probably would’ve landed with more…well, grace. Right now, though, it’s part of the furniture—an old, worn-out couch that you still might kick back on now and then, but you know full well that its best days are long behind it.

For fans of: Chelsea Grin, Carnifex, Thy Art Is Murder

‘Graceless’ by Suicide Silence is released on 20th November on Century Media Records.

Words by Luke Nuttall

Leave a Reply