
To get the obligatory housekeeping out the way first, this is only the fourth Down album, despite being called Volume V. That’s because its preceding volume comprised the two EPs released in 2012 and 2014, as both parts of a single installment. Not exactly a clean numbering system, but for a band who sound like embodiment of bayou filth, ‘clean’ isn’t a mandatory aspiration.
It’s also kind of incredible that we’re getting a new full-length from Down at all. Over a decade’s drought of material is one thing, but what really sticks is how a more comprehensive who’s-who of a metal subgenre is yet to be seen. Phil Anselmo; Pepper Keenan of Corrosion Of Conformity; Kirk Windstein of Crowbar (returned to the fold since 2019); Pat Bruders, also of Crowbar; and Jimmy Bowen of Eyehategod. As unfashionable as the term ‘supergroup’ has become, Down are indisputably it within sludge-metal.
What benefits them a lot on Volume V is how much it feels like a product of the as-and-when nature of new music, as well as sludge-metal’s predilection towards older, more grizzled performers. The looseness combined with its prove-nothing-to-nobody attitude is foundational in getting great work from Down, maybe more than ever. Nothing on Volume V seems meticulous or overly tampered-with; it’s five lifers who’ve defined NOLA metal over the decades, reconvening because they clearly want to. You could call it a passion project if even that weren’t indicative of an aim that’s too high.
Instead, Volume V rocks because every man involved is a total natural at what they do. That does, unfortunately, mean having to praise Phil Anselmo, but when he emerges like a monster from the swamp to snarl, gravel and gurn his way along, there’s no other way around it. If anything, he might be the best showcase of how instinct is Down’s greatest trait. Range is rarely a factor, nor does it need to be when his aura is so absolute, from tip to tail. There’s a frankly disgusting amount of attitude in Anselmo’s numerous vocal stims (“Keep it simpleeeee!” bellows The Message; “Drive slow, ride heavy,” churns out Causeway Grief), almost to the point of chewing the musical scenery. He really does sound like an implacable man-mountain at any given moment.
The sole outlier is Ozz, where Down shift gears and seem noticeably unconvincing at doing so. It’s a tribute to Ozzy Osbourne that’s undoubtedly heartfelt, but in its formless acoustic guitar and Anselmo’s word-association blubbering, it sounds as though it was made up on the spot. At least with the rest of Volume V—songs built around riffs that also could’ve been feasibly improvised—there’s a titanic well of confidence to override that feeling. Down’s best is raucous and uncompromising to a fault, music that has its genesis in the early, evil days of blues and rock ‘n’ roll. When that’s in the clear firing line on Volume V, it’s unbeatable.
The vibe is ultimately what pushes the album over the top, once again. There’s almost a jammed-out feel to it that’s so appealing every time it materialises. Merciful Fate diverts into stoner-rock with its swinging bass roil and Livia Zita’s backing vocals almost designed to emulate oppressive heat haze. Later songs play even more wryly, like the fat trad-metal grunt of They Walk The Night, or They Came From Dust which is effectively Down’s coarse, spluttering take on an AC/DC riff.
The kernel of fun glinting amid the blackened sludge shouldn’t go ignored; it’s imperative to Down’s game plan. Even with someone like Anselmo at the helm, whose stress-testing vocals practically implore you to picture the vein bulging from his forehead, the unparalleled joys of riffin’ are meant to speak for themselves. Keenan has described the NOLA sound as “slippery”, and that’s a great encapsulation of how Volume V plays out. It’s the way that Turn Out The Light and Blood Oath are so Sabbath-coded, yet never fully succumb to doom or dread. It’s supposed to be this yelling, borderline righteous experience of heavy music making. When songs do spill over six or seven minutes, you can almost believe that it’s because Keenan and Windstein are so transfixed by what their guitars have smelted.
If that were true, you couldn’t blame them for it. Again, the entire band are on exceptional form and Volume V is enriched from every drop of inspiration. Bruders deserves a special shoutout for bass contributions that can still leap out among the riffery; he’s the outright star of Merciful Fate’s first leg, but Blood Oath and Twice-Told Tales have him clop along with thick, tangible intent. Bowen arguably gets the fewest true standout moments on drums, but as ever in sludge-metal, a caving percussive base shouldn’t be underestimated. All together, Down are one hell of a unit. In this sphere of music, they feel almost equipped for anything, be that pivots into trad-metal, or deliberate, bleary sludge, or an acid bubble of stoner guitar on Merciful Fate that might be the single best creative choice on this entire album.
It says mountains when one of the few noteworthily ‘bad’ moments on Volume V isn’t even from Down themselves, rather the wear-and-tear befalling King Diamond’s falsetto on Merciful Fate. Otherwise, Down themselves are working at a pretty ludicrous level here. For pre-existing fans of The Sludge, there’s no earthly reason why Volume V wouldn’t appeal, but even under the blanket category of ‘metal’, there’s no reason at all that this couldn’t appeal. Simply put, Down are that good at what they do, and infectious enough in their gumption to obliterate subgenre boundaries for one of the best heavy releases of the year. Couldn’t have been more worth the wait, honestly.
For fans of: Corrosion Of Conformity, Crowbar, Black Label Society
‘Volume V’ by Down is released on 20th November on Nuclear Blast Records
Words by Luke Nuttall






